I was introduced to him via Playstation All-Stars Battle Royal, and his cold, self-assured blandess immediately made me dislike him almost instantly. On top of that, Yahtzee Chroshaw's mostly negative review of-
...Oh, wait, I've done this before, haven't I?
So here's Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, a game that many people have been comparing to DmC Devil May Cry ever since the conception of both, because fanboys will argue over anything given the chance. It doesn't help that both are action-based hack-and-slashers starring borderline-pubescant, unlikable protagonists with a pencheant for over-the-top violence and cringe-worthy dialogue, nor that both games were outsourced to a third party because the original producers couldn't trust themselves to do anything with it. But it does help that the both of them have significantly different feels, when one gets right down to it, and it also helps that when two similar games come out, for some strange reason people are only prepared to buy one or the other, rather than have both (thank you, CeX vouchers!). So because I don't know any better, let's compare the two games and find out which of these is "best"!
Steel Komodo presents:
DmC Devil May Cry vs. Metal Gear Rising
Plot!
DmC loses several million points right out of the gate by being written by Temmem Antoniades, who, as we have established, is a self-righteous prick with all the empathy a glass of water conjures. From then on, it's pretty much downhill - the dialogue often descends into foul-mouthed teenage back-and-forthing which, while funny in a ridiculous kind of way, makes Joss Whedon's constant parade of one-liners look like Shakespeare. The social commentary is about a subtle as a sledgehammer to the face, as the organization which Dante must take down to ensure humanity's freedom might as well have been called Nox Fews, and on top of that not a single character is relatable in any measure, and you know something is wrong when you hate your player character more than you hate the giant, vomit-spewing maggot demon you're supposed to be fighting.
MGR's plot, by comparison, is a lot stronger. By Kojima standards, it's pretty simple - Raiden good, war bad, kill cyborgs - but has enough intruige and curveballs to keep the player interested. There's a host of intruiging and likeable characters, each with quirks beyond "wears a silly hat" and "swears all the time", that I found myself getting oddly attached to - we transition from the somewhat psychopathic yet informative Doktor easing us into tutorials to the reassuring tones of Boris to give us mission directions, with geeky nerd girl Courtney to save game progress and comedic foil Kevin to tell us why we should give a shit. Drama and laughs come from all sides, and one truly feels that there is an appreciable threat that we need to hunt down and eliminate, not some nebulous corporate miasma that we only tangientally grasp. Definitely better than most of Kojima's efforts, which apparently were desperate attempts to stop making Metal Gear games, I've read.
DmC: 0
MGR: 1
Protagonists!
Dante and Raiden - two malnourished teens with giant swords, bland personalities and odd dress sense. The two make an interesting contrast of each other - on the one hand, a cybernetic ninja with traditional honour values who fights PMC's because it's his job, and on the other, a half-demon slacker who fights demons because he's got nothing better to do that day. One dresses in what can only be called a metallic fetish outfit complete with high-heels and ass-hugging bodysuit, whilst the other wears the first wifebeater, coat and jeans he could find that morning. It's like a metaphor for class separation, if you'll forgive the amount of pretentiousness in that sentence.
In all seriousness, though, I think I prefer Dante over Raiden here. Okay, so he spouts off F-Bombs and punches out bodyguards like a sulky teenager who isn't getting his own way, but there was a very clear sense that he's facing something huge that he can only barely comprehend. The demonic foe is huge, omnipresent and pretty much hates him on sight, and there is a real uncertainty at times if Dante can even take on something so big it literally controls most of humanity behind the scenes, like a mouse trying to fight a humpback whale. Raiden, however, is backed by a technologically-advanced PMC with loads of money in their pockets and all the latest gadgets, and can cut entire buildings apart with a single swipe of his sword. It's hard to root for someone who doesn't feel like he can be threatened by anything, and that's why Dante is (relatively) more relatable than Raiden despite his constant abuse of the word fuck.
DmC: 1
MGR: 1
Combat!
Let's talk about the big gimmick of MGR first - Blade Mode. Once you've stuck an enemy, you can hold down Left Trigger and slow down time, allowing you to rattle the Right Analog Stick about and dice the foe into pieces. A blue meter beneath Raiden's health bar slowly decreases as you slice, and once it runs down you exit Blade Mode and can't use the slow-mo feature the next time you activate it. You get more points for the more pieces you cut an enemy into, and if you cut at a specific location you can then press B to follow up with the Zandatsu, which allows you to recover health and energy and nets you even more points. It feels awesome when you get it right, and the game makes a big thing of how you can cut practically anything with it, which must have been a programming nightmare - kudos to the man who managed to get that working!
However, Blade Mode only works when the game isn't asking you to make precise, fine movements. This is the sort of game where you can be surrounded by soldiers and helicopters vomiting missiles and bullets from every direction, and you can't stop to be accurate or else a Gekko might sneak up and stick his foot up Raiden's arse. But then the game asks you to precisely slice a hand off certain soldiers to obtain data, and even the Zandatsu requires that you precisely target a small orange box on the victim's stomach, and Blade Mode itself is inexact and wild by nature. It's entirely possible to waste your entire energy bar trying to strike a specific point on the target which won't hold still long enough for you to do so, and this is extremely aggrivating as well as flow-breaking.
It doesn't help that combat itself is rather awkward and sticky, and lacks the flow one expects from a hack-and-slasher. Every fight consists of the following, ad nauseum: beat an enemy long enough to render him vulnerable, dice him up with Blade Mode, perform Zandatsu, rinse and repeat. I don't know why the ability to perform actual air combos has to be bought as an upgrade, but the designer needs a slap in the face for that, because I only found this out when my attempts at dicing an opponent in midair failed because what I thought was the launcher can't be comboed from. There's nothing akin to DmC's chains or dash strikes to keep up the pace of battle, and so there's always a period where you'll be running around trying to find that one last enemy that keeps shooting you from really far away. And when you have a game mechanic (i.e., the parry system) that can be outwitted by rubbing the controller on your knee, then it might be worth not bothering at all.
DmC has it's combat down right - you have a variety of weapons that can be chained together for mind-buggeringly long combos, you have a mechanic that lets you jump from one enemy to the next to keep the flow going, and it's generally more fast-paced and frantic. It's basically being about the beauty of combat itself, rather than trying to build up to a spectacular end result that gets boring and stale after you've turned an enemy into prawn salad for the umpteenth time. On top of that, whilst Raiden is pretty much stuck with his sword and can only use rocket-launchers for the occasional hard-to-hit enemy, Dante wields things like flaming gloves and a scythe that can be swapped between during combat to adapt for every challenge, making you feel untouchable.
Also, where the fuck is dodge?! This might sound petty, but I won't apologize for having gotten used to being able to leap out of the way of a sneaky chainsaw attack coming from the corner of my eye. In MGR, if an enemy attacks you from behind whilst you're busy with his mate, you might as well have your cyber-trousers around your ankles.
DmC: 2
MGR: 1
Upgrades!
Okay, MGR definitely takes the prize for this one, because the benefits that might be had for having multiple weapons in DmC are compounded by the upgrade system being like an overly-complex DnD sheet. You acquire upgrade points based on how well you do in combat, but they come so sparsely that you have to think very hard about which skills you want to buy, especially early in the game when you have no idea if Trillion Stab is better than Bullet Rain or so on. On top of that, you have to level up your skills as well as buy new ones, but all your attacks are equally effective on the hordes anyway, so any upgrades to attack damage or speed don't seem rather pointless when you can just stunlock the enemy to death and get equally productive results.
MGR's upgrade system is much more refined: you have a currency, which you earn from killing all enemies, and you buy skills and upgrades with that currency like a shop of murder. And more to the point, each skill feels absolutely nessecary - Raiden needs all the edge he can get against things like unmaned helicopters, robot wolves and giant metal dinosaurs. All the skills in DmC are just more stylish ways of inflicting damage, and whilst there's nothing particulary wrong with that you could potentially proceed through the game without even buying all of them, which strikes me as missing the point somewhat. In a hack-and-slasher, the player needs to evolve in order to take out an increasingly dangerous threat, and there's nothing threatening about a giant demon that can be defeated by abusing the basic combos without any hinderance.
DmC: 2
MGR: 2
Exploration!
This one I agonized over a bit, because both titles have considerable flaws in this aspect. On the one hand, MGR's story focus means that exploration is severely limited, each level being mostly linear with little to no deviations in the path between battle arenas as a consequence of trying to show off epic setpieces. On the other hand, DmC's exploration is hampered by the game's obnoxious habit of blocking off areas in a level that require you to return after obtaining items from later levels, forcing people to replay the first few handfuls of missions in order to get 100% completion on them. This meant a lot of umming and hawing on this subject.
But in the long run, DmC gets the prize because at least there's actual exploration in it. Most importantly, there's an actual reason to do it - finding the keys and challenge doors to find the neccesary upgrade points one needs to make Dante stronger. On top of that, finding all the Lost Souls nets you a bonus amount of currency, which one needs to buy items to keep going in the game, and all MGR has to offer you is rocket launchers. Not a bad reward, but when ammo is scarce due to the focus on melee combat, rockets are pretty much a liability.
DmC: 3
MGR: 2
Setpieces!
Of course, what would a hack and slasher be without fancy environments to hack apart your foes in? MGR does a good job of creating high-octane action by having sequences where Raiden runs along a moving train, down a collapsing clock tower while fighting a Metal Gear RAY and battling enemy cyborgs on top of a stormy tower. But the trouble with these is that they aren't exactly awe-inspiring or original - they feel like sequences ripped from a Borne or Bond movie that we've seen a hundred times before. The environments themselves are nothing to write home about, either, mostly consisting of ruined streets or military bases and little else besides. On top of that, the dull, greyish-brown pallette means that no matter how exciting the cutcenes get, they lack a certain punch that just a bit more vibrant colour could have added.
DmC, however, takes the proveribal chocolate cake when coming up with environment design. When Dante is propelled into Limbo, the realm of the demons that lies just behind the human world, everything turns red and hazy and gains a clear desire to murder the poor drifter in violent ways. The scenery itself shifts and rips in desperate attempts to kill Dante, glowing letters flashing accross the landscape to try and demoralize us. And from murderous carnivals and a run-down mansion decaying with age, we move to hopping up floating boxes in a demonic drinks factory to swinging through corridors fromed from bombastic news logos. There's even a sequence during the battle with evil newscaster Bob Barbas where Dante is monitored by a news camera as he dices up enemies, complete with scrolling text below filled with blatant lies about how handsome the villain is. They're silly, they're unique and they're fun, which is more than can be said for Street #124 Raiden is running down.
DmC: 4
MGR: 2
And the winner is...
DmC Devil May Cry
So there you go. In my own opinion, DmC is a much more interesting and unique game than Metal Gear Rising. Of course, this is just my opinion - both games have their merits, and one could arge that there's a place for both games on any gamer's shelf, regardless of dumb fanboy wars or negative press. DmC does some things better, and MGR does other things better, and it all boils down to what you as a consumer want from your hack-and-slashers. So if you have the disposable income, get either game you fancy, because they're both great on their own merits and one shouldn't let petty arguments and personal feelings stand in the way of their overall quality. Who knows? Perhaps if they were to combine, they could produce the greatest game in the hack-and-slash genre to ever exist, dethroning God of War from it's throne of skulls and decapitations.
Also, to the Metal Gear fanboys who I know will be off to humiliate themselves in the comments by saying MGR should have won this...
No comments:
Post a Comment